Why Was Pastor Jimmy Odukoya Removed?

The leadership crisis at The Fountain of Life Church, Lagos, has escalated following conflicting announcements over the removal of its Senior Pastor, Pastor Jimmy Odukoya, by a faction of the church’s Board of Trustees.
What initially appeared to be a straightforward removal has developed into a dispute over succession, constitutional authority, the late founder’s wishes and the standards expected of the church’s spiritual leadership.
Importantly, as of November 18, 2026, the removal is contested, not an undisputed or settled decision.
A. Disagreement over the late founder’s succession plan
Pastor Jimmy became Senior Pastor following the death of his father, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, founder of The Fountain of Life Church, who died on August 7, 2023.
Jimmy’s appointment was announced in September 2023 and was presented as a leadership transition following his father’s death.
However, a group of trustees now claims that a previously undisclosed video recording, allegedly made in December 2021, contains Taiwo Odukoya’s instructions for a different succession arrangement.
According to the trustees, the late founder designated another minister, identified in a subsequently released recording as Pastor Kunle Areogun, to succeed him.
They further claimed that Jimmy was expected to serve as the designated successor’s administrative assistant and head of the youth church, rather than take over as Senior Pastor.
The trustees alleged that the recording was not presented during the deliberations that resulted in Jimmy’s appointment in 2023. They consequently described his appointment as inconsistent with the founder’s wishes.
B. Concerns over Jimmy Odukoya’s remarriage
The trustees also cited his recent remarriage as part of their concerns.
Jimmy introduced his new wife, Pastor Mo Odukoya, to the congregation during a church service on November 1, 2026. Pastor Tunde Bakare reportedly blessed the marriage, which had taken place in the United States.
Jimmy was previously married to Oluwakemi Banjoko, with whom he has two children.
The trustees argued that the remarriage and its public blessing conflicted with the church’s teachings, the founders’ values and the standards expected of its spiritual leadership.
However, the reasons behind the breakdown of his first marriage have not been independently established in the public reports.
C. Failed reconciliation efforts
The trustees claimed that they had spent months attempting to resolve the disagreement privately, including consulting respected Christian leaders.
According to their account, Jimmy did not accept the advice offered during those reconciliation efforts.
These claims formed part of the explanation given for their decision to withdraw recognition of his leadership.
The development took another turn on November 17 when The Fountain of Life Church issued a counterstatement rejecting the purported removal.
The church described the decision as unconstitutional and insisted that the individuals who announced it lacked the authority to remove Jimmy.
Its position rests on three arguments:
Jimmy was unanimously appointed Senior Pastor by the Board of Trustees in September 2023.
The trustees behind the removal announcement had allegedly been asked to resign from the Board since March 14, 2026, over alleged constitutional violations.
The church maintains that no constitutionally valid Board decision has removed Jimmy from office.
The church therefore reaffirmed him as its duly appointed Senior Pastor and Chairman of the Board of Trustees.
This means the church’s official position directly contradicts the removal announcement.
3. Has another pastor been appointed?
Yes. The trustees who announced Jimmy’s removal subsequently named Pastor Rotimi Okpaise as interim spiritual and administrative leader.
However, this appointment is also part of the disputed leadership arrangement. The church has not accepted the authority of the faction making these announcements.
The trustees say the interim arrangement will provide continuity while a substantive leadership structure is established.
Here is the position based on the latest available reporting:
Issue Current position
Jimmy’s removal Announced by a faction of trustees
Jimmy’s response Rejects the removal
Church’s position Says he remains Senior Pastor
Succession recording Released by the trustees
Proposed successor Pastor Kunle Areogun
Interim leader Pastor Rotimi Okpaise, appointed by the opposing trustees
Final resolution No publicly established resolution
PUNCH’s November 18 report confirms that two groups are making competing claims over the church’s leadership. No publicly confirmed legal or institutional resolution settling the dispute has been reported.
Beyond the personalities involved, this controversy raises important questions for church governance:
Can a founder’s recorded succession instructions override a leadership appointment already approved by the Board of Trustees?
Was the 2023 appointment made without full disclosure of relevant succession information?
Who has the constitutional authority to appoint or remove a Senior Pastor?
To what extent should a minister’s marital circumstances determine eligibility for church leadership?
How should churches resolve internal leadership disagreements without dividing their congregations?
These questions remain central to the unfolding situation.






















